3 key quotes from Trump’s first State of the Union, explained

By
Veronica Lee
-
167
4767

Steven Pressman, Colorado State University; Greg Wright, University of California, Merced, and Stephanie L. Canizales, University of Southern California – Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences

Editor’s note: President Donald Trump, in his first State of the Union address, took credit for a growing economy, urged Congress to invest more in infrastructure and defense and promoted an immigration plan that ties citizenship for Dreamers to border security and an end to family-based migration. During the 80-minute speech – the third-longest State of the Union – he touched on a wide range of topics, from the opioid crisis and MS-13 to North Korea and foreign aid. We asked three academics to choose key quotes and add the context missing from the president’s words.

Stick to the facts – they’re good enough

Greg Wright, University of California, Merced

“This is in fact our new American moment. There has never been a better time to start living the American Dream.”

To back this up, Trump said we’re finally seeing rising wages after years of stagnation, noted that the stock market is smashing “one record after another” and highlighted Apple’s recent plan to “invest a total of $350 billion in America” and hire 20,000 workers.

While the newness of this moment in American history is debatable, the economy under President Trump is following a well-worn path set down by the previous administration. And that’s fairly good news indeed. The question is, can he claim credit for any of it?

It is true that we are finally seeing rising wages, but these gains go back well into the Obama administration, and in fact the past year has seen only modest wage growth. The stock market’s winning streak is impressive. Of course, this trend also began under Obama.

The key point is that these economic trends are largely beyond the control of the current administration, or any administration, for better or worse. As an example, real income fell over Trump’s first year in office in part due to rising inflation, which eats into every dollar’s buying power. There’s not a lot a president can do about inflation.

What about increased investment by U.S. companies like Apple? Here the president is on surer footing in claiming that the tax cuts he signed into law last year are having an impact. Unfortunately, Apple is not investing $350 billion – at least not yet, it’s simply repatriating money it has always had access to – and its plans to add 20,000 jobs appear largely unrelated to tax cuts or other government policies.

At the same time, the tax cuts will undoubtedly spur new capital investments, some of which may eventually lead to modest pay raises for U.S. workers, credit for which should go to President Trump and congressional Republicans.

Trump also highlighted Exxon Mobil’s very recent announcement that it will invest billions in the U.S. as a response to the tax bill. Once again, Trump’s actual words turned out to be too good to be true. He boasted $50 billion, but $15 billion of that was previously announced. Still, $35 billion as a result of the tax cuts is serious money.

In summary, on the economic front there is basically good news. Good enough, in fact, to be honest with the American people about the state of the union.

The state of our infrastructure

Steven Pressman, Colorado State University

“It is time to rebuild our crumbling infrastructure … I am asking both parties to come together to give us the safe, fast, reliable and modern infrastructure our economy needs and our people deserve.”

The president is right about this. U.S. infrastructure is in utter disrepair. The American Society of Civil Engineers gave it a D+ grade in its most recent report. Trump proposed spending $1.5 trillion to fix the problem.

While tackling it is surely necessary, the president’s solution is flawed in terms of both timing and method.

First, the timing. An infrastructure program was needed in 2009, after the U.S. economy collapsed and job creation was paramount. But today, unemployment stands at 4.1 percent, near full employment. The new tax law passed in December will likely further boost spending and reduce unemployment. Except during wars, when young men were fighting overseas rather than making things in the U.S., the unemployment rate has rarely dipped below 4 percent over the past 70 years. With immigration off the table, where will we find the workers to build this infrastructure?

Second, in terms of method, the president wants state and local governments to “partner” in infrastructure projects and pay part of the cost. This will require that they raise taxes. Areas in good financial health, such as New York City, will be able to do this. Areas struggling economically and in most desperate need, such as Flint, Michigan, will not.

In my view, the economic problem we face today is not insufficient spending, which an infrastructure program would remedy, but excessive corporate power that is hurting American workers. The real incomes of full-time U.S. workers, which have stagnated for decades, fell by 1 percent in 2017 alone, even as stocks and CEO pay soared.

The solution to this problem involves strengthening worker rights, not weakening them, as the Trump administration policies have been doing. I believe giving workers a meaningful raise is far more important than improving our nation’s infrastructure – as bad as it is, our paychecks are worse.

A non-compromise on immigration

Stephanie L. Canizales, University of Southern California

“It is time to reform these outdated immigration rules and finally bring our immigration system into the 21st century. These four pillars represent a down-the-middle compromise, and one that will create a safe, modern and lawful immigration system.”

The four pillars the president outlined in his speech include a path to citizenship for 1.8 million immigrants brought to the U.S. as undocumented children, increased border enforcement, termination of the visa lottery and an end to “chain migration.”

I believe the first proposal rightfully brings Dreamers out of limbo, and I applaud the president for taking this stand. The other three “pillars,” however, rest on shaky foundations that deserve closer scrutiny.

Trump’s second pillar – more border enforcement – seems to be premised on the notion that new immigrants are synonymous with drugs, gangs and depressed job and wage growth, and that only his “beautiful wall” and more border agents can protect Americans. This ignores the fact that immigrants are less likely to commit serious crimes than native-born Americans. As for MS-13, which Trump spotlighted as a source of violence in his speech, it is a homegrown gang, born and bred in the streets of Los Angeles, California, not native to Central America.

As for claims that immigrants hurt natives, the evidence is clear and substantial that they do not. Little competition occurs for the low-wage occupations that employ undocumented immigrants, such as those in agriculture, garment manufacturing, and domestic work. In fact, removing immigrants would hurt our economy through the loss of sales taxes, property taxes and other economic contributions.

Trump’s third proposal, to terminate the visa lottery, willfully misrepresents immigration law. The diversity visa lottery – despite its name – does not “randomly hand out green cards” but allocates 50,000 visas each year to countries with low rates of migration. To be eligible, applicants must meet various educational, occupational, security and health criteria.

And his fourth pillar not only contains falsehoods but a derogatory slur that dehumanizes the men, women and children who seek a new life in the U.S. Trump’s desire to end “chain migration” rests on claims, which he repeated in the address, that immigrants with permission to remain in the U.S. exploit current policy by sponsoring “virtually unlimited numbers of distant relatives” to join them.

This is far from the truth. Only parents, spouses and unmarried minor children may be sponsored through family-based immigration.

The ConversationThe pillars Trump proposes are not, in my view, a “down-the-middle” compromise with the guarantee of a “safe, modern and lawful” system. If lawmakers agree to such a plan, all immigrant communities would pay a steep price, even if protecting Dreamers is a worthy goal.

Steven Pressman, Professor of Economics, Colorado State University; Greg Wright, Assistant Professor of Economics, University of California, Merced, and Stephanie L. Canizales, Ph.D. Candidate, University of Southern California – Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

167 COMMENTS

  1. Покупая грузовик, не стоит слепо верить бумажкам. Важнее смотреть на «здоровье» техники вживую — как она ездит, какие звуки издает, как работает гидравлика.
    https://t.me/s/kupit_gruzoviki/79

  2. Канал с обзорами и сравнениями грузовой техники для выбора и покупки.
    Публикуем новости, технические характеристики, рыночную аналитику, советы по выбору для бизнеса.
    У нас всегда актуальные цены и тренды рынка СНГ! Подпишись:
    Будущее коммунальной техники: автоматизация и экология

  10. Официальный Telegram канал Live Сasinо. Кaзинo и ставки от лучших площадок. Доступны актуальные зеркала официальных сайтов. Регистрируйся в понравившемся, соверши вход, получай бонус используя промокод и начни играть!
    https://t.me/s/iGaming_live/110

  63. ПОДПИСЫВАЙСЯ! В канале:
    • Только лицензированные LIVE-казино
    • Рабочие зеркала 24/7
    • Анализ стратегий для рулетки/блэкджека
    • ПРОМОКОДЫ с фриспинами
    Регистрируйся > Играй в live-дилеров > Выводи BTC!
    https://t.me/s/iGaming_live/2000

  70. В НАШЕМ КАНАЛЕ ТЕБЕ ДОСТУПНО:
    ?? Рейтинг проверенных LIVE-площадок
    ?? Зеркала с мгновенным доступом
    ?? Бонусы до 500% + 200 фриспинов
    ?? Стратегии для Mega Ball и Deal or No Deal
    РЕГИСТРИРУЙСЯ И ВЫВОДИ ВЫИГРЫШИ БЕЗ ВЕРИФИКАЦИИ!
    https://t.me/s/iGaming_live/3500

  97. Hmm is anyone else having problems with the pictures on this blog loading? I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog. Any responses would be greatly appreciated.
    Limo service near me

  98. Simply desire to say your article is as surprising. The clarity for your submit is simply nice and that i could assume you’re an expert in this subject. Fine together with your permission allow me to clutch your feed to keep updated with impending post. Thanks 1,000,000 and please continue the rewarding work.
    cat casino официальный

  99. This is very attention-grabbing, You’re an excessively professional blogger. I have joined your feed and look forward to in search of extra of your fantastic post. Additionally, I have shared your website in my social networks
    вход Banda Casino

  102. трип скан Tripscan – это ваш личный компас в мире безграничных путешествий, надежный проводник, открывающий двери к незабываемым приключениям и уникальным культурным открытиям.

  118. Путин Зеленский Специальная военная операция (СВО) в корне изменила геополитический ландшафт. Политика превратилась в арену ожесточенной борьбы, где каждое действие, каждое слово имеет вес. Переговоры, в которых ключевые роли играют Владимир Путин и Владимир Зеленский, стали символом надежды на мирное разрешение конфликта, но и отражением глубоких противоречий. Финансовый аспект СВО оказал мощное влияние на мировую экономику. Санкции, волатильность рынков, перебои в поставках – все это создает серьезные вызовы для Европы, Азии и Америки. Безопасность и оборона вышли на первый план, заставляя страны пересматривать свою военную стратегию и укреплять обороноспособность. Кавказ и Ближний Восток, всегда находившиеся в зоне повышенного риска, столкнулись с обострением существующих конфликтов и возникновением новых угроз. В этой сложной обстановке новости и аналитика должны быть максимально объективными и непредвзятыми, чтобы люди могли составить собственное мнение и принять взвешенные решения.

  120. Students, professionals, and hobbyists alike rely on OneConverter.com as a trusted resource. High school students use it to complete homework questions, ensuring they understand how to convert between units of volume or temperature. College researchers appreciate its scientific precision when dealing with complex conversions in physics or engineering. Business professionals often need quick currency or time zone calculations to plan international meetings; this site delivers those results instantly. DIY enthusiasts measure materials for home improvement projects by converting square feet to square meters or gallons to liters. Photographers evaluate storage needs by converting between megabytes and gigabytes. Fitness trainers track distances and energy expenditure by switching between miles and kilometers or calories and kilojoules. With OneConverter, there’s no need to memorize dozens of conversion factors—just input your number, choose your units, and the answer appears. The clear layout and straightforward instructions help users learn as they go, making the site both a tool and a teaching aid. Regardless of your field or expertise level, OneConverter.com provides the conversions you need, right when you need them.
    OneConverter|

  121. WebPtoPNGHero.com exists to solve a common problem: not all programs support the WebP format. This free online converter makes it easy to transform WebP pictures into PNG files that work everywhere. To get started, upload one or more WebP images by dragging them into the designated area or clicking the upload button. Behind the scenes, powerful server routines convert each file while preserving sharpness and color accuracy. A status bar displays conversion progress, and finished PNG files appear with download links in mere seconds. Batch processing allows entire folders of images to convert simultaneously, which is ideal for photographers or webmasters dealing with large photo libraries. The browser-based design eliminates compatibility headaches—Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, and iOS devices all run the tool without issues. Privacy measures delete uploaded images automatically after a short interval, and no personal data sticks around. Whether you’re a professional graphic designer or a casual user, this ad-free service offers fast, reliable conversions without requiring any registration or payment.
    webptopnghero converter

  122. At JPGtoPNGHero.com, converting JPG images into PNG format is fast and straightforward. The homepage features a clear drag-and-drop area and a prominent “Convert” button. Simply drop your files or browse to select them; the server will process each image, maintaining sharpness and color fidelity. Once conversion finishes, download links appear below each file, ready for you to save. For users handling multiple images, batch mode lets you queue dozens of files in a single session. Because everything runs in a web browser, no software installations or plugins are needed—just load the site on your computer, tablet, or smartphone. Compatibility spans Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, and iOS without exceptions. Privacy measures ensure that all uploaded images disappear from the server shortly after processing, and no data is retained. Whether you’re preparing graphics for a blog, optimizing photos for an online portfolio, or simply converting vacation snapshots, JPGtoPNGHero.com delivers a seamless experience. Best of all, it’s free: no sign-up, no ads, and no hidden fees—just reliable, unlimited image conversions.
    jpgtopnghero converter

  125. истории путешествий обычных людей Грустные истории из жизни обычных людей Жизнь не всегда бывает легкой и безоблачной. Порой нас настигают утраты, разочарования и трудности, справиться с которыми кажется невозможным. Истории о боли, потере и преодолении горя помогают нам сопереживать чужому несчастью, находить в себе силы идти дальше и ценить каждый момент жизни. Они учат нас состраданию и пониманию того, что мы не одиноки в своей печали.

  131. Planning a trip to the Dominican Republic? Whether you’re headed to the stunning beaches of Punta Cana, the historic streets of Santo Domingo, or the picturesque city of Puerto Plata, arranging your Dominican Republic airport transfers is a must for a stress-free start to your vacation. The good news? The Dominican Republic offers a variety of airport transfers options to suit every traveler’s needs and budget.
    dominican republic airport transfers

  138. Привет!
    Ты сильно ошибаешься, и вот почему. [url=https://generik-info.ru/analogi-lekarstv-deshevle/]Что такое дженерики лекарства[/url]
    Переходи: – https://generik-info.ru/analogi-lekarstv-deshevle/
    Что такое дженерики лекарства
    Дженерики для чего они нужны
    Что такое дженерики в медицине

    До встречи!

  146. программа для учета ремонта автомобилей Для торговых предприятий программы учета позволяют вести учет товаров, продаж, остатков, проводить анализ эффективности и формировать отчетность. Это помогает принимать обоснованные управленческие решения и повышать прибыльность бизнеса.

  153. Эскорт работа Тюмень Работа для девушек в Тюмени: Новые возможности для амбициозных и уверенных в себе. Элитное общение, достойный заработок и полная свобода. Воплоти свои мечты в реальность!

  155. J’adore le casino TonyBet, ca ressemble a un univers de jeu unique. La selection de machines est vaste, incluant des slots ultra-modernes. Les agents sont reactifs, offrant un excellent suivi. Les transactions sont securisees, par contre les offres pourraient etre plus genereuses. Globalement, TonyBet est une plateforme fiable pour les fans de jeux en ligne ! Ajoutons que, l’interface est fluide, ce qui rend l’experience encore meilleure.
    tonybet echtgeld|

  156. заказ цветов в москве День рождения – особенный праздник, и цветы – прекрасный способ поздравить именинника. Учитывайте его предпочтения, возраст и пол при выборе букета. Цветы на 8 марта: Символ весны и женственности

  157. J’adore a fond Azur Casino, il offre une aventure captivante. Les options de jeu sont impressionnantes, incluant des slots dynamiques. Les agents sont d’une efficacite remarquable, offrant des reponses claires et rapides. Les retraits sont ultra-rapides, neanmoins davantage de recompenses seraient bienvenues. Dans l’ensemble, Azur Casino ne decoit jamais pour les amateurs de jeux en ligne ! Notons egalement que l’interface est fluide et elegante, ce qui rend chaque session memorable.

    gГ©ant casino centre azur hyeres|

  158. Je suis epoustoufle par le casino AllySpin, c’est une veritable plongee dans le divertissement. Les options de jeu sont incroyablement variees, comprenant des jeux innovants. Le personnel est d’un professionnalisme exemplaire, offrant des solutions rapides. Les retraits sont super rapides, cependant les promos pourraient etre plus genereuses. Pour faire court, AllySpin vaut vraiment le detour pour les amateurs de casino en ligne ! En prime le style visuel est dynamique, facilitant chaque session.
    allyspin giocare per soldi|

  159. J’apprecie enormement Banzai Casino, on dirait une plongee dans le divertissement intense. La selection est riche et diversifiee, avec des machines a sous ultra-modernes. Le personnel est d’un professionnalisme hors pair, avec un suivi de qualite. Les transactions sont parfaitement protegees, cependant davantage de recompenses seraient un plus. En conclusion, Banzai Casino est une plateforme incontournable pour les amateurs de jeux en ligne ! Notons aussi que l’interface est fluide et moderne, ce qui intensifie le plaisir de jouer.
    banzai casino en ligne|

  160. Je suis enthousiaste a propos de Betclic Casino, on dirait une energie de jeu irresistible. Les options de jeu sont vastes et diversifiees, avec des machines a sous modernes et captivantes. Le support est d’une reactivite exemplaire, joignable 24/7. Les retraits sont ultra-rapides, occasionnellement les bonus pourraient etre plus frequents. En resume, Betclic Casino vaut amplement le detour pour les joueurs en quete d’adrenaline ! Ajoutons que le site est concu avec elegance, renforce l’immersion totale.
    betclic paris sportif|

  161. J’aime enormement le casino TonyBet, ca offre un plaisir de jeu constant. Les options de jeu sont nombreuses, offrant des options de casino en direct. Le support est toujours la, tres professionnel. On recupere ses gains vite, cependant plus de tours gratuits seraient bien. Globalement, TonyBet vaut vraiment le coup pour les adeptes de sensations fortes ! De plus, la plateforme est intuitive, ce qui rend l’experience encore meilleure.
    tonybet freispiele 2022|

  162. Je suis epoustoufle par le casino AllySpin, c’est une veritable energie de jeu incroyable. La selection de jeux est immense, avec des machines a sous captivantes. Le support est ultra-reactif, offrant des solutions rapides. Les retraits sont super rapides, mais parfois plus de tours gratuits seraient top. En resume, AllySpin vaut vraiment le detour pour les passionnes de jeux ! Par ailleurs la navigation est fluide, renforcant l’immersion.
    allyspin giocare online|

  163. J’apprecie enormement Azur Casino, ca procure une sensation de casino unique. Les options de jeu sont impressionnantes, offrant des jeux de table elegants. Le personnel est hautement professionnel, garantissant une assistance de qualite. Les gains sont verses rapidement, neanmoins les bonus pourraient etre plus nombreux. Pour conclure, Azur Casino ne decoit jamais pour les adeptes de sensations fortes ! En bonus la navigation est intuitive et agreable, amplifiant le plaisir du jeu.

    azur casino offres|

  164. J’apprecie enormement Banzai Casino, ca offre une experience de jeu explosive. Il y a une multitude de titres varies, proposant des jeux de table authentiques. Le support est ultra-reactif, repondant en un eclair. Le processus de retrait est simple et efficace, neanmoins plus de tours gratuits seraient apprecies. En conclusion, Banzai Casino vaut largement le detour pour ceux qui aiment parier ! Notons aussi que le site est concu avec dynamisme, ajoutant une touche d’elegance et d’energie.
    banzai slots offres|

  165. Je suis enthousiaste a propos de Betclic Casino, on dirait une energie de jeu irresistible. La selection de jeux est phenomenale, incluant des slots dernier cri. Le personnel offre un accompagnement de qualite, offrant des reponses rapides et precises. Les gains sont verses en un clin d’?il, cependant j’aimerais plus d’offres promotionnelles. En resume, Betclic Casino est une plateforme d’exception pour ceux qui aiment parier ! De plus la navigation est simple et agreable, facilite chaque session de jeu.
    rГ©sultats betclic elite|

  166. салон красоты севастополь татуаж севастополь — Татуаж бровей, век и губ в Севастополе пользуется большой популярностью у тех, кто хочет сэкономить время на ежедневном макияже или получить чёткую, выразительную форму надолго. В городе доступны разные техники: волосковый микроблейдинг для естественного эффекта, порошковый или пудровый татуаж для мягкой растушёвки, комбинированная техника и омбре-эффект для глубины цвета. Перед процедурой мастер обязательно проводит консультацию, согласует форму, оттенок и показывает эскиз; также обсуждаются противопоказания — беременность, некоторые кожные заболевания, склонность к келоидным рубцам и приём препаратов, влияющих на свёртываемость крови. Зафиксированный пигмент со временем бледнеет, поэтому рекомендуется коррекция через 4–12 недель после первичной процедуры и поддерживающие процедуры каждые 1–3 года в зависимости от типа кожи и образа жизни (частые загары и пилинги ускоряют выцветание). Важную роль в качестве татуажа играет гигиена и безопасность: лицензированные мастера используют одноразовые иглы, стерильные инструменты и высококачественные пигменты, соответствующие международным стандартам. После процедуры возможны отёк и корочки, требуется деликатный уход — избегать воды, загара, активного спорта и агрессивной косметики на время заживления; мастер даст детальную памятку. При выборе салона в Севастополе обращайте внимание на длительность опыта мастера, наличие сертификатов, портфолио с реальными фото «до/после» и возможность теста на пигмент в случае чувствительной кожи.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here